Guide to the Guild Guides

Post Reply
User avatar
Infragris
Project Administrator
Posts: 1396
Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2015 7:51 pm

Guide to the Guild Guides

Post by Infragris »

Part of a larger effort to define and contextualize teleportation magic within Tamrielic culture. This explains why teleportation is not more commonplace and why it hasn't had a massive effect on the way the Empire functions (yet).

I don't consider this one quite ready yet, but since I'm not going to be available for a while I figured I'd post it so the basic premise can be discussed openly.
GUIDE TO THE GUILD GUIDES
An Essay on Modern Arcane Transportation Methods
by Hroka

With the advent of the modern Celaudine method, the cumbersome and expensive teleportation systems of our ancestors became obsolete. Since then, these spells have been rationalized to the point that even a novice can apply them with some degree of success. What's more, the work of sages such as Suma Prenja resulted in a framework for the creation of enchanted objects which can transport their wearer to a specific location without fail.

With all these advancements, many laymen now question why teleportation is not more widespread in our lives. Why do we need ships and caravans, why must armies march and lay siege to fotresses, why even bother building vaults and walls, if one can bypass them by magic?

To answer these questions, we must investigate three key issues which inhibit a the application of teleportation: location, distance, and specialization.


I: LOCATION
Location is fairly straightforward. If one is to transport oneself or others by magic, one must first know one's destination. To this end, a “spiritual anchor” must be established in the location one wishes to go. In simple terms: one can only go where one has been before.

This restriction explains why teleportation to distant locales is not more commonplace, as few mages have the means (or inclination) to travel far and wide for such a purpose.

Additionally, the ability to maintain multiple "marked" locations is extremely rare outside the specialized training of the Guild Guides, who at best can maintain spiritual anchors in four distinct locations. Even then, connections may waver, a Guide can become confused, or, rarely, an anchor can snap without warning – a phenomenon still ill-understood.

Methods of teleportation that do not require pre-knowledge of the destination do exist, but they are without exception extremely dangerous. The Barilzaritic method was reportedly capable of bypassing these and any other restrictions, but the secret of this method has been lost centuries ago, and further investigation has been forbidden.

There are other obstructions, too. Many places in this world, by natural or artificial means, are capable of inhibiting teleportation. Extreme energies generated by the presence of powerful magical fields can overwhelm the signature of the spiritual anchor, leaving its counter-spell protocol without the required thaumatic "handshake". Other, more subtle means rely on the interference of invisible vibrations. Machines producing such frequencies are used in most Imperial prisons, and, as teleportation becomes more commonplace, we can expect such machines to become a mainstay in any number of settings.


II: DISTANCE
The issue of distance and the expenditure of magic is not difficult to explain. When transporting someone, the magicka and level of concentration required rise sharply beyond a certain threshold in the Lucevarius Curve.

This means that, while teleportation in a range of several miles is fairly simple, the same spell across large distances requires exponentially more magicka. To teleport from Daggerfall to Wayrest is somewhat draining for a standard practitioner. But to teleport from High Rock to Yokuda would require more magicka than a thousand mages in concert could harness.

These calculations do not even come close to describing the requirements in terms of willpower. Even enchantments face insurmountable physical limits in this regard – there are accounts of spellscrolls and amulets which crumble to dust when the requested anchor is too far away, and one (particularly gruesome) story of a man whose enchanted helmet had fused into his skin upon teleporting.

Such horror stories pale in comparison to the real danger of long distance teleportation. The anchor connection can grow unstable, disgorging the passenger somewhere along the way (sometimes without their possessions) or dumping them in the general vicinity of their anchor point, ranging from feet to several miles. But some never return at all – caught, it is believed, between dimensions, utterly cut off from the Mundus in a liminal space from which escape is impossible.

A note should be made of teleportation to and from the realms of Oblivion. First, keep in mind that the infamous gateways to those principalities do not function by the rules described aboce, but by the pacts of the Daedra (though it is often said that their existence inspired the first forays into teleportation). Likewise, the summoning and binding of Daedra by means of conjuration is a completely different field of study, with its own rules and bylaws.

Rumors claim that some mages can use spiritual anchors to return to Nirn from Oblivion or, in the case of the very audacious, travelling to an anchor set withing such a realm. Such tales have never been verified, and, according to standard theories, travel across such vast rifts would require double-folded spatial astrolometries to boggle the mind of even a true master of enchantment and mysticism - if such a master even exists.

Though unlikely, it may be that the very concept of "distance" is entirely irrelevant in this regard, which would suggest that the planes of Oblivion are not cosmically far removed from us, but rather only a hair's breadth away from us, intangible yet ever present. Such a disquiting theory seems entirely improbable, which is why it is best to discount these tales of inter-planar teleportation is unsubstantial myths.


III: SPECIALIZATION
The training of the so-called Guild Guides, mages specialized in the art of mass teleportation, requires lifelong study. This rather unglamorous field, more akin to a ferryman than a master of the mystic arts, has often been derided in academia – the career path is a classic suggestion for students lacking talent or aspiration.

Despite this, proper Guide study is actually one of the most intensive fields of arcane practice. Standard teleportation spells are all aimed at transporting the caster, sometimes in addition to another person, but never to the exclusion of the caster. The few mages who attempted to wield teleportation offensively quickly discovered this issue.

This implicit bias is an inherent flaw in the Celaudine spell architecture, which Guide students must actively train to overcome lest they transport themselves alongside their client.

In addition, most mages can barely handle one spiritual anchor, while Guild Guides must master multiple simultaneous destinations without causing mishaps, "collisions" or other such unfortunate logistical problems.

The routine disrespect, lack of promotion opportunities, unfashionable postings, and high requirements for Guild Guide study make quality Guides relatively rare. Most Guilds can afford to keep a Guide or two on retainer, but it is often difficult to replace one that is sick or incapacitated.

This, too, explains the relative lack of enchanted objects that are designed to send the wielder to one place or another – most guild guides are so specialized in their field that the arts of enchanting are almost completely unknown to them.

These three aspects – location, distance, and specialization – are not the only ones that inhibit the widespread usage of teleportation. However, they are the most pertinent ones, and should suffice to explain why the widespread use of teleportation to ease our lives is still some ways off.

User avatar
Taniquetil
Site Admin
Posts: 1162
Joined: Sun Jun 25, 2017 8:25 am

Post by Taniquetil »

Reviewing this fantastic text so it can finally be merged.
"With the advent of the modern Celaudine method, the cumbersome and expensive teleportation systems of our ancestors became obsolete."
I'd insert "in the second era" after "method", for a bit more specificity with the "since then" in the next sentence.
What's more, the work of sages such as Suma Prenja resulted in a framework for the creation of enchanted objects which can transport their wearer to a specific location without fail.
A somewhat awkward sentence in the passive voice. Could be maybe rewritten to "What's more, sages such as Suma Prenja have developed a framework for the creation of enchanted objects which can transport their wearer to a specific location without fail."
With all these advancements, many laymen now question why teleportation is not more widespread in our lives.
I'd change "with" to "amidst".
To answer these questions, we must investigate three key issues which inhibit a the application of teleportation: location, distance, and specialization.
Typo here after "inhibit" (superfluous "a"). I'd also add the word "magic" after "teleportation".
To this end, a “spiritual anchor” must be established in the location one wishes to go.
Odd wording on the end, best changed to something like "must be established at the intended destination."
In simple terms: one can only go where one has been before.
Would sound less stilted written as "In simple terms, this means that one can only go where one has been before."
The Barilzaritic method was reportedly capable of bypassing these and any other restrictions, but the secret of this method has been lost centuries ago, and further investigation has been forbidden
Forbidden by whom? I'd also change "has been lost" to "was lost".
Machines producing such frequencies are used in most Imperial prisons, and, as teleportation becomes more commonplace, we can expect such machines to become a mainstay in any number of settings.
Since it seems likely that we won't be able to implement this kind of machine in gameplay for some time, and probably only in unique locations, it might be worth adding some words about this technology being very new/rare/restricted/etc.
This means that, while teleportation in a range of several miles is fairly simple, the same spell across large distances requires exponentially more magicka. To teleport from Daggerfall to Wayrest is somewhat draining for a standard practitioner. But to teleport from High Rock to Yokuda would require more magicka than a thousand mages in concert could harness.
Couple of issues here. Comma after "that" in the first line needs to go. "To teleport" in the second and third lines should change to "Teleporting". The third line is a fragment, and needs to be combined with the second as "Teleporting from Daggerfall to Wayrest is somewhat draining for a standard practitioner, but teleporting from High Rock to Yokuda would require more magicka than a thousand mages in concert could harness."
one (particularly gruesome) story of a man whose enchanted helmet had fused into his skin upon teleporting.
"Particularly gruesome" does not need to be in parentheses. I'd also dump the "had" in "had fused".
Such horror stories pale in comparison to the real danger of long distance teleportation.
Needs a hyphen between "long-distance".
First, keep in mind that the infamous gateways to those principalities do not function by the rules described aboce, but by the pacts of the Daedra (though it is often said that their existence inspired the first forays into teleportation).
Would change the beginning of this sentence to not address the reader so directly (incongruous with the style elsewhere in the text). Could just cut everything before "the infamous gateways". Also typo "aboce" -> "above".
Rumors claim that some mages can use spiritual anchors to return to Nirn from Oblivion or, in the case of the very audacious, travelling to an anchor set withing such a realm.
Needs an em-dash or comma after "Oblivion". "Travelling" -> "traveling".Actually, this should just be "travel". Typo "withing" -> "within".
Though unlikely, it may be that the very concept of "distance" is entirely irrelevant in this regard, which would suggest that the planes of Oblivion are not cosmically far removed from us, but rather only a hair's breadth away from us, intangible yet ever present
Kind of awkwardly worded - might be better as something like:
"Some scholars suggest that the mortal concept of "distance" is entirely irrelevant to teleportation within Oblivion. If true, this perspective would suggest that the planes of Oblivion are not cosmically distant from us, but rather only a hair's breadth away - intangible, yet ever present."
Such a disquiting theory seems entirely improbable, which is why it is best to discount these tales of inter-planar teleportation is unsubstantial myths.
Typo "disquiting" -> "disquieting".
This rather unglamorous field, more akin to a ferryman than a master of the mystic arts, has often been derided in academia – the career path is a classic suggestion for students lacking talent or aspiration.
I'd add "in the popular imagination" after "akin", since it seems unlikely that an author writing on the guild guides would trash the guild guides like this. Also, the clause after the em-dash should be its own sentence. Maybe worth adding "of magic" after "students" - this role still requires magical aptitude, after all, as the next paragraph makes clear.
Despite this, proper Guide study is actually one of the most intensive fields of arcane practice.
Despite what? Maybe "Despite its dull reputation"?
Standard teleportation spells are all aimed at transporting the caster, sometimes in addition to another person, but never to the exclusion of the caster.
Should be rewritten to something like "Standard teleportation spells transport the caster - sometimes alongside other persons - but never exclude the caster."
The few mages who attempted to wield teleportation offensively quickly discovered this issue.
Would change this to read "Mages who have attempted to wield teleportation magic offensively have quickly discovered this issue."
This implicit bias is an inherent flaw in the Celaudine spell architecture, which Guide students must actively train to overcome lest they transport themselves alongside their client.
Would rewrite this as "This implicit bias towards the spellcaster is an inherent flaw in Celaudine spell architecture - a flaw which Guide students must actively train to overcome, lest they accidentally transport themselves alongside their client."
In addition, most mages can barely handle one spiritual anchor, while Guild Guides must master multiple simultaneous destinations without causing mishaps, "collisions" or other such unfortunate logistical problems.
I would split this into two sentences.
This, too, explains the relative lack of enchanted objects that are designed to send the wielder to one place or another – most guild guides are so specialized in their field that the arts of enchanting are almost completely unknown to them.
Would change this to two sentences as well. Also, add the word "rarity" after "this" in the first sentence.
These three aspects – location, distance, and specialization – are not the only ones that inhibit the widespread usage of teleportation. However, they are the most pertinent ones, and should suffice to explain why the widespread use of teleportation to ease our lives is still some ways off.
I'd change the end of this to read "why the widespread use of teleportation magic to ease our lives remains somewhat out of reach" or similar.

All these edits applied to the original text:
Spoiler
GUIDE TO THE GUILD GUIDES
An Essay on Modern Arcane Transportation Methods
by Hroka

With the advent of the modern Celaudine method in the Second Era, the cumbersome and expensive teleportation systems of our ancestors became obsolete. Since then, these spells have been rationalized to the point that even a novice can apply them with some degree of success. What's more, sages such as Suma Prenja have developed a framework for the creation of enchanted objects which can transport their wearer to a specific location without fail.

Amidst all these advancements, many laymen now question why teleportation is not more widespread in our lives. Why do we need ships and caravans, why must armies march and lay siege to fotresses, why even bother building vaults and walls, if one can bypass them by magic?

To answer these questions, we must investigate three key issues which inhibit the application of teleportation magic: location, distance, and specialization.


I: LOCATION
Location is fairly straightforward. If one is to transport oneself or others by magic, one must first know one's destination. To this end, a “spiritual anchor” must be established at the intended destination. In simple terms, this means that one can only go where one has been before.

This restriction explains why teleportation to distant locales is not more commonplace, as few mages have the means (or inclination) to travel far and wide for such a purpose.

Additionally, the ability to maintain multiple "marked" locations is extremely rare outside the specialized training of the Guild Guides, who at best can maintain spiritual anchors in four distinct locations. Even then, connections may waver, a Guide can become confused, or, rarely, an anchor can snap without warning – a phenomenon still ill-understood.

Methods of teleportation that do not require pre-knowledge of the destination do exist, but they are without exception extremely dangerous. The Barilzaritic method was reportedly capable of bypassing these and any other restrictions, but the secret of this method was lost centuries ago, and further investigation has been forbidden by Imperial authorities.

There are other obstructions, too. Many places in this world, by natural or artificial means, are capable of inhibiting teleportation. Extreme energies generated by the presence of powerful magical fields can overwhelm the signature of the spiritual anchor, leaving its counter-spell protocol without the required thaumatic "handshake". Other, more subtle means rely on the interference of invisible vibrations. Machines producing such frequencies are now used in some Imperial prisons. As teleportation becomes more commonplace, we can expect such devices to become a mainstay in any number of settings.


II: DISTANCE
The issue of distance and the expenditure of magic is not difficult to explain. When transporting someone, the magicka and level of concentration required rise sharply beyond a certain threshold in the Lucevarius Curve.

This means that while teleportation in a range of several miles is fairly simple, the same spell across large distances requires exponentially more magicka. Teleporting from Daggerfall to Wayrest is somewhat draining for a standard practitioner, but teleporting from High Rock to Yokuda would require more magicka than a thousand mages in concert could harness.

These calculations do not even come close to describing the requirements in terms of willpower. Even enchantments face insurmountable physical limits in this regard - there are accounts of spellscrolls and amulets which crumble to dust when the requested anchor is too far away, and one particularly gruesome story of a man whose enchanted helmet fused into his skin upon teleporting.

Such horror stories pale in comparison to the real danger of long-distance teleportation. The anchor connection can grow unstable, disgorging the passenger somewhere along the way (sometimes without their possessions) or dumping them in the general vicinity of their anchor point, ranging from feet to several miles. But some never return at all – caught, it is believed, between dimensions, utterly cut off from the Mundus in a liminal space from which escape is impossible.

A note should be made of teleportation to and from the realms of Oblivion. The infamous gateways to those principalities do not function by the rules described above, but by the pacts of the Daedra (though it is often said that their existence inspired the first forays into teleportation). Likewise, the summoning and binding of Daedra by means of conjuration is a completely different field of study, with its own rules and bylaws.

Rumors claim that some mages can use spiritual anchors to return to Nirn from Oblivion - or, in the case of the very audacious, travel to an anchor set within such a realm. Such tales have never been verified, and, according to standard theories, travel across such vast rifts would require double-folded spatial astrolometries to boggle the mind of even a true master of enchantment and mysticism - if such a master even exists.

Some scholars suggest that the mortal concept of "distance" is entirely irrelevant to teleportation within Oblivion. If true, this perspective would suggest that the planes of Oblivion are not cosmically distant from us, but rather only a hair's breadth away - intangible, yet ever present. Such a disquieting theory seems entirely improbable, which is why it is best to discount these tales of inter-planar teleportation is unsubstantial myths.


III: SPECIALIZATION
The training of the so-called Guild Guides, mages specialized in the art of mass teleportation, requires lifelong study. This rather unglamorous field, more akin in the popular imagination to that a ferryman than a master of the mystic arts, has often been derided in academia. The career path is a classic suggestion for students of magic lacking talent or aspiration.

Despite this dull reputation, proper Guide study is actually one of the most intensive fields of arcane practice. Standard teleportation spells transport the caster - sometimes alongside other persons - but never exclude the caster. Mages who have attempted to wield teleportation magic offensively have quickly discovered this issue.

This implicit bias is an inherent flaw in the Celaudine spell architecture, which Guide students must actively train to overcome lest they transport themselves alongside their client. Furthermore, most mages can barely handle one spiritual anchor. Guild Guides, on the other hand, must master multiple simultaneous destinations without causing mishaps, "collisions" or other such unfortunate logistical problems.

The routine disrespect, lack of promotion opportunities, unfashionable postings, and high requirements for Guild Guide study make quality Guides relatively rare. Most Guilds can afford to keep a Guide or two on retainer, but it is often difficult to replace one that is sick or incapacitated.

This rarity, too, explains the relative lack of enchanted objects that are designed to send the wielder to one place or another. Most guild guides are so specialized in their field that the arts of enchanting are almost completely unknown to them.

These three aspects – location, distance, and specialization – are not the only ones that inhibit the widespread usage of teleportation. However, they are the most pertinent ones, and should suffice to explain why the widespread use of teleportation magic to ease our lives remains somewhat out of reach.
A far green country, under a swift sunrise
she/her

User avatar
Infragris
Project Administrator
Posts: 1396
Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2015 7:51 pm

Post by Infragris »

Two more small errors in the last paragraph of the Distance section
Though unlikely, it may be that the very concept of "distance" is entirely irrelevant in this regard, which would suggest that the planes of Oblivion are not cosmically far removed from us, but rather only a hair's breadth away from us, intangible yet ever present. Such a disquieting theory seems entirely improbable, which is why it is best to discount these tales of inter-planar teleportation as unsubstantial myths.
Small content update, replace "Guilds" with "guildhalls" here:
Most guildhalls can afford to keep a Guide or two on retainer, but it is often difficult to replace one that is sick or incapacitated.
No further comments, this looks good to go.

Post Reply

Return to “P:C Literature”